It took Pakistan 4 consecutive and heavy defeats for them to realise that on flat pitches, the rechristened England is not only tough to contain but is almost impossible to defeat them. Once, they turned to spin as their main choice of attack, England, the Bazballers were found wanting. On every previous occasion, Pakistan have always resorted to spin and were able to overcome England, though a much subdued team than the correct one, rather comfortably. Why did the choose to play on flat pitches is beyond anyone. Perhaps, to bolster the figures of a certain Babar Azam. Nevertheless, it is England that must be worried about their performance rather than Pakistan.
The signs are indeed worrying for England. Until the start of this year, they had a fabulous record in Asia. Consecutive series wins in Sri Lanka and a series sweep in Pakistan. Sri Lanka were very weak to begin with and Pakistan laid out pitches that satisfied the urge of England. Once they arrived in India, save for a freakish Pope innings, they could have easily lost 0-5. The point is that their inability on spinning pitches is in stark contrast to their mastery of placid tracks. England does not seem to have an alternate method for such pitches. Bazball does not mean that you play the same way as you have always done. If that is the case, it is ridiculous.
Batsmen all at sea
The technique of a majority of their batsmen is open for question. Zak Crawley, Ollie Pope, Ben Stokes and Harry Brook, all of them do not possess the technique for such pitches. Root is the only exception but the problem is that, Root, who is otherwise known for tall scores, though he possesses the necessary technique, is not prepared to stay at the wicket for long or is incapable of staying at the wicket. Perhaps, that is because of Bazball which promotes aggressive batting but which at the sametime, confuses the mind into playing shots were there was none to play. Infact, Harry Brook did not look resemble even an iota of the batsman who had reeled off 4 consecutive hundreds in Pakistan including a triple.
Geoffrey Boycott, the much respected batsman and a much more admired commentator, laid into the England batsmen.
“If you want to be rated a great batsman, you must have a rounded game, and score runs on all types of pitches,” the Yorkshireman said.
“They are entertaining and fantastic to watch because you never know what they are going to do next, good or bad, but Ben Stokes and Brendon McCullum want their team to be the best. Unfortunately they are wasting their opportunity and risk being remembered as flat-track bullies unless they adjust for conditions.”
The Stokes McCullum legacy
I am afraid that the legacy of Stokes and McCullum and that of Bazball has been tarnished by yet another series defeat when challenged. The incredible pace of scoring runs and the several unconventional shots are all beautiful to watch in the familiar environs of England but when the same proves to be their downfall, England will have to change their approach to more traditional forms of the game. The inability to adapt their game to the conditions is proving to be their biggest stumbling block. As soon as they are confronted with such pitches, they are mentally defeated. They are unsure of how to approach the innings. When a team is mentally defeated, it sure is a recipe for disaster.
Asian teams are often accused of being strong at home but hopeless outside of Asia. Much the same can be said about every team with the exception of Australia, who usually transcends conditions. They possess the necessary skills to survive.
Now, it must be noted that none of these pitches, either in India or Pakistan were rank turners. They were all traditional Asian pitches that are slow and low with liberal help for the spinners. England did not learn any lesson from their loss in India. It was hardly 6 months ago and yet, they approached these games with the same mindset. See the ball, hit the ball. It worked in the first Test at Multan but from the moment Pakistan realised their folly, things came unstuck for England. There is no point in complaining about pitches because every side does that. Even the pitches in the SENA countries, help their method of bowling.
Wrapping up Bazballers were found wanting
It is all well and good for Stokes and McCullum to dream about becoming the best team in the world. They must remember to change their approach based upon the conditions. They can continue with their Bazball approach on placid tracks which it must be admitted, offers them an unique advantage because they are able to give their bowlers much more time. On the otherhand, If there is bounce or spin on the pitch, it is better to put the Bazball cricket on the backburner and follow traditional method.